Sunday, July 19, 2020

From Roger Fitch and our friends down under at Justinian

A gangster in the White House

SCOTUS rules on Electoral College voting ... Sexual identity and civil rights ... Native-American reservations ... Dreamers ... Presidential tax records ... The power of theocrats and churches ... Some helpful rulings, others less so ... Justice Department habitually supporting Trump's personal battles in court ... Curious belief that a mentally unfit president could be reelected ... Maybe it is possible ... Roger Fitch reports from Washington 

The 2019 supreme court term has ended. Here's who won and who lost.

First the good news. 

"Faithless electors" can be punished; the decision was unanimous - dealing with situations where members of the Electoral College seek to defy the will of a state's voters. 

In a Louisiana case, the court ended non-unanimous jury verdicts in state felony trials. Linda Greenhouse was fascinated by the hidden agendas revealed in the individual opinions.

In Bostock, a majority supported a literal reading of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 so as to cover sexual identity and orientation. The conservative Trump appointee Neil Gorsuch joined the court's liberals and wrote the opinion. The Atlantic recounts the fortuitous presence of the word "sex" in American anti-discrimination law.

Bostock will affect overtly discriminatory Health and Human Services regulations recently announced by Trump and under legal attack, but religious zealots hope to use their claims to circumvent the new ruling. Some observers suspect Gorsuch laid landmines in Bostock to further future conservative initiatives.

In Indian Country (as we say) there was the momentous McGirt decision, again featuring Justice Gorsuch, who affirmed the enduring validity of Native-American reservations covering vast areas of eastern Oklahoma.  

In the DACA decision (Trump v NAACP), Chief Justice Roberts joined the court's liberals in finding that the Trump administration's efforts to abolish President Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals  failed, not because it couldn't be done, but because of the sloppy way it was attempted. 

Citing respect for precedent, the newly-fluid CJ also joined a liberal majority in June Medical Services v Russo, striking down a Louisiana abortion restriction almost identical to one found unconstitutional by a differently-composed court in 2016. 

And then there were unfortunate cases.

As feared by legal writers, more here, faith-based discrimination triumphed at the supreme court, with the Espinoza decision finally giving theocrats victory. Other religious indulgences granted by the supreme court include Little Sisters of the Poor (the "nuns case") about contraception coverage, and the Biel and Morrissey-Berru "religious functions" cases that widely expand a "ministerial" exception to employment discrimination laws.  

The decision to preference religions came just in time for churches (notably Catholics) to secure "Covid" government loans, even where their financial straits stemmed from ruinous sexual-abuse payouts.

A disturbing suspension of habeas in immigration cases was countenanced in the Thuraissigiam case, damaging the important Boumediene precedent. 

The resolution of Trump's financial subpoena problems was needlessly postponed in Trump v Mazars and Trump v Vance: the controversy continues. 

It's unclear what effect the subpoena cases will have on the McGahn case currently on appeal. That's the astonishing case in which a Republican-dominated panel of the DC court of appeals conveniently ruled that federal courts can't enforce congressional subpoenas against employees of  the executive branch. House Democrats appealed to a full bench who have heard the case but not yet ruled.   

Gorsuch: suspected of laying landmines

In a number of cases this term the Justice Department inappropriately supported Trump personally, e.g, in the subpoena cases. The new term will have (depending on election results) further disreputable Justice interventions, e.g, to find Obamacare unconstitutional, and (building on a 2018 decision) to shield US corporations from liability under the Alien Tort Statute for human rights abuses abroad (more here on DoJ's shameful brief). 

•   •   •

Overseas commentators imbibing American media's "bothsidesism" portray the US as a country gripped in battle between two evenly-matched, morally-equivalent political parties with sincerely-held views, each vying for the voters' support. Even so, according to this doomsday narrative, an insoluble "partisan" deadlock in the US is leading to a "failed state".

Not infrequently, it's assumed - without basis - that Donald Trump, a man who lost the popular vote in 2016 (his polls have rarely risen above the low-40s since), whose psychiatric-based 25th Amendment removal was already under discussion in January 2017, who helped his party lose 48 House seats in 2018 and was actually impeached in 2019, is somehow representative of, and likely to be re-elected by, a majority of Americans, despite the devastating consequences that would bring to their country. 

It's an insulting assertion, blaming the victims rather than the actual architect of America's current dysfunction: the gangster in the White House, the worst-ever leader in US history.

Native fascism has indeed received popular support in America before, but only a cynical belief that crime pays, and Americans are mulishly stupid, explains the notion of an openly-corrupt, mentally-ill conman winning re-election. 

A substantial number of Trump voters have soured on him, and won't vote for him again. At best, his support may approach the highest free-election achievement of another evil demagogue. 

Der Führer retained office by avoiding further free elections; sadly, there are two ways (here and here) that a defeated Trump might also contrive to remain in office.

Thursday, June 18, 2020

From Roger Fitch and our Friends Down Under at Justinian

The republic in flames

Trump has found his Roy Cohn ... The Pussy Grabber waves a bible ... Sacking inspectors general en masse ... Grifters united ... Attempts to politicise the armed services ... Roger Fitch files from Washington 

"He Is Even Dumber Than We Thought" - New Republic headline.

 "As limited as his mental capacity is, he needs no assistance in thinking of ways to grab things that he wants, whether it is vaginas or political power, legal limitations be damned" - Justia.

"Trump is a 'predator' who 'would be in prison' if he hadn't been born rich" - clinical psychiatrist.

 "Trump has reached the 'mad emperor' stage, and it's terrifying to behold" - Guardian headline.

Abetted by Attorney General William Barr (a man compared to Carl Schmitt and Roy Cohn), Donald Trump has long searched for a Reichstag Fire to further his authoritarian agenda (more here), and he thought he'd found one in the George Floyd protests sweeping the US.

It started with his (disputed) discovery that he controlled the District of Columbia National Guard, and might bring in out-of-state National Guards. Immediately, America's infantile president was like a child with a new toy: a new weapon to use, not just against demonstrators, but also the media.

On June first, Trump emerged from his White House bunker. His usual Schutzstaffel augmented with a  mysterious unmarked paramilitary force (either an FBI hostage rescue team or Bureau of Prisons Special Operations Response Team), America's Caudillo strode across Pennsylvania Avenue to St John's Church, followed by his AG, his defence secretary and worst of all, a fatigue-clad (now contrite) head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. 

St John's precincts had been violently cleared of peaceful demonstrators by the thuggish AG; in the space provided, a photo-op was staged. Having just promised to send in the army, America's godless leader now stood before the church brandishing a bible, a repudiation of separation of church and state as well as  freedom of assembly. 

The Episcopal bishop was outraged, but Trump was unrepentant, having recently claimed the non-existent power to force states to open churches. 

Trump with his Schutzstaffel - on the way to church 

It seemed a simple stunt designed to beat up the president's bestial "base", but Americans were alarmed by a new danger: a politicised military, as quickly recognised by the military itself. An earlier military showdown in Washington (in 1932) ended badly for another Republican president. 

Was this threatened coup the moment the shameless president went too far for the tolerant (race-aside) Americans? His polls sank. Ex-officials and some Republican senators began speaking out. More here.

•   •   •

It should have happened sooner. Behind the theatre, there is nothing innocent about Trump's flagrant deregulatory corruption and criminal mischief. The president is using the pandemic pretext to kill health and environmental regulations, even flout court orders, while ingratiating himself with supporters by funding church salaries, tormenting sexual minorities and reviving barbaric hunting practices.  

Every lever of government has been corruptly co-opted, and even alternative civil institutions of the Republican Party have been subverted: the Federalist Society has become a Trump tool rather than a vehicle for conservative legal sentiment. More here. 

Ransacking the republic has required the removal of inspectors general en masse. These "Stalinist" purges should be a national scandal; their purpose, other than revenge (the Intelligence IG who forwarded the Ukraine extortion whistleblower's account to congress) and punishment, is to forestall any investigations of the president, at least until after the election. 

The first high-level victim was the Office of Personnel Management chief; others followed, including Glenn Fine, the newly-named IG charged with oversight of disbursal of the corona virus appropriations, and the IGs for both Defence (also Glenn Fine) and the State Department. 

It's not just IGs being sacked, witness Rick Bright, an official who declined to recommend the dangerous anti-malarial drug Trump had been spruiking, along with other nostrums peddled by his mates. 

deVos: regulations to protect dodgy "educational" institutions 

For some of Trump's new placemen - who often have conflicts of interest - it's a prize: a mediocre Texas congressman, John Ratcliffe, was awarded Chief of Intelligence for obstructing Trump's impeachment. 

The president also believes in looking after grifters like himself. New regulations cobbled together by his odious Education Secretary Betsy deVos are designed to protect proprietors of unscrupulous "colleges" like Trump University from student actions and remedies. Congress overturned her regulations, but Trump vetoed the disallowance (more deVos skulduggery here).

•   •   •

Some discern a constructive abdication by Trump of his constitutional role as president. Why doesn't he just retire, go back to shady real estate deals, TV shows and personal (as opposed to public) branding? 

Admittedly, if he clings to power four more years, lots of criminal statutes of limitations will run out.

He'd also have more time to settle old scores before he leaves, e.g, bring back unrestrained defamation (unless he's the target), although this could backfire.America: The Smoking Ruin

As it is, he's hurting The Party, and looks like taking the senate down with him.  

Either way, the country will be a smoking ruin when he goes. 

Saturday, May 23, 2020

From Roger Fitch and our friend down under at Justinian

The plot thickens

SCOTUS tussle over congressional subpoenas for Trump's financial records ... Presidential immunity rejected in Nixon and Clinton cases ... Republicans want a compliant Supreme Court ... Yet, POTUS not doing well in the lower courts ... Attorney General's political manipulation of the judiciary ... Alarms and diversions for the election... Roger Fitch files from Washington  
We sometimes forget that Donald Trump won office with 26.3% of eligible voters (Hillary got 26.5%).
It's still a shock to see a transparently unsuitable person direct the whole US government, even as he rages against it, yet under the peculiar American presidential system of government, he can. As a consequence, a country ravaged by virus is at the same time mismanaged and pillaged by an administration stuffed with party operatives, corporate lobbyists and special interests, staffed with the unqualified and incompetent. 
As for the hyper-litigious and "paranoid" president, his own day of judgment arrived in the supreme court, where his astonishing claims to be above the law were considered in oral arguments conducted by telephone. More here and here. 
Sadly, the court looks set to buy into some of Trump's (bad faith) claims that congress acted in bad faith in issuing subpoenas for financial records held by third parties such as Deutsche Bank and his accountants Mazars. 
The institutions stand ready to obey the subpoenas, but Trump argued that doesn't matter: their compliance with law would "burden" his presidency. 
As Marty Lederman noted, the president produced no evidence of actual burdens. Instead, he relied upon deceptively-described Justice Department memoranda to support his position, just as Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin used a DOJ memo to block release of Trump's tax returns to  congress, notwithstanding a statute specifically authorising subpoenas for taxpayer returns.
The president's obvious goal is to keep his financial improprieties secret until at least after the election.
Previous supreme courts unanimously rejected similar claims of presidential privilege and immunity by presidents Nixon and Clinton. Will things be different with an ideologically-packed supreme court? 
If the court allows Trump's arguments to stand, it would signal that a major political party has secured a durable partisan alignment of justices for the benefit of the party's sitting president. 
But the Republicans want more: they want a supreme court dependably aligned with the party itself, as in Wisconsin. 
In 2000, long before the Trump court was in place, a partisan faction of the supreme court installed an unelected president, in Bush v Gore. Experts are debating whether it could happen again this year. 
Neomi Rao: reliable DC Trump judge opposed to release of Mueller grand jury evidence
Many are reflecting on the fact that the supreme court would now have a 5-4 liberal composition, had the Republican senate not stonewalled Obama's nominee Merrick Garland until the Democrat president's term expired. That court might have taken a very different view of Trump's remarkable claims.
The president is losing in the lower courts. A 4th circuit decision allows the foreign emoluments case against Trump to go forward, and the DC circuit has upheld a district court's decision that the secret grand jury evidence from the Mueller inquiry must be disclosed to congress pursuant to a House Judiciary Committee subpoena - reliably dissenting was Neomi Rao; she and Gregory Katsis, another Trump appointee, are already proving their worth to the party. 
In a desperate attempt to suppress the grand jury testimony, the government has asked the supreme court to set aside the DC circuit's decision.
There's still a DC en banc ruling pending in the McGahn case, a review of a three-judge panel's decision in which two Republican judges inexplicably endorsed the amazing view that congress can't enforce any subpoenas against executive branch employees. 
With six months to go, Trump's election-year strategy has emerged: discredit the Mueller inquiry, and partly supported by his attorney general, create external scandals: the absurd, Trumped-up "Obamagate". 
Barr: unstitching the Mueller convictions
In federal district courts, AG Bill Barr has been systematically sabotaging cases arising from the special counsel's report, while his dishonest response to an FOI case requesting the full report prompted DC judge Reggie Walton to rebuke the AG and question his candour. 
In the Roger Stone case, the Attorney General's flagrant meddling was successfully resisted by DC judge Amy Jackson Berman. Stone has been sentenced, though temporarily reprieved due to the corona crisis.
Barr interfered next in the trial of former national security director Michael Flynn, also indicted during the Mueller investigation. After installing outside counsel to review the case, Barr pushed out career prosecutors and filed for dismissal of the case, even though the retired general had already pleaded guilty - twice.
The Flynn judge, Emmet Sullivan, could reject the government's motion, and Barr, perhaps unwisely, has sneered at his critics, who call his submissions faulty, and likely to incite frivolous arguments in future criminal cases. 
Judge Sullivan has now appointed outside counsel to argue the case against dismissal. More here. 
The Attorney General's political manipulation of the courts has shocked lawyers, and over 2000 former DOJ officers have called for Barr's dismissal. 
Progressive organisations discern a Republican plot, now reaching fruition, to use the courts to undo most 20th century advances in federal and state legislation (report here).

Friday, April 17, 2020

From Roger Fitch and our friends down under.

The war-time president

Managing the pandemic in the US of A ... Letting the virus out of the bottle as the president bloviates and botches ... Ideology trumps science ... Misinterpreting the Defence Procurement Act ... Disbanding and closing programs for pandemic preparedness ... US manufacturers busily exporting vital equipment ... Oversight provisions in rescue legislation to be ignored ... Roger Fitch's Letter from Washington 
 
"I didn't know people die from the flu."
Donald Trump, unaware that Frederick Trump, his enterprising immigrant grandfather, died in the 1918 flu pandemic.
*   *   *
"We've had a big problem with the ... woman governor ... from Michigan. We don't like to see the complaints ... Now, she wants a declaration of emergency, and, you know, we'll have to make a decision on that ... [but] all she does is ... blame the federal government."
Donald Trump, bullying a blue state governor through threats to withhold coronavirus aid.
*   *   *
"They had things [in the Democrats' proposed legislation], levels of voting that if you'd ever agreed to it, you'd never have a Republican elected in this country again." 
Donald Trump, conceding that improved access to voting during the pandemic would cost his party office.  
*   *   *
Character is destiny, and America's kakistocrat president is dealing with the coronavirus crisis as only he would. The Post has an overview of Trump's shocking, dysfunctional response.
Mr Trump seized on the crisis, not to save lives, but to preen and bloviate about himself, and punish Democrats, too. For example, presidential declarations of a local state of emergency trigger federal financial support and assistance, and Trump has mostly green-lighted these for Republican states, while delaying them for Democrat-governed states. More here and here.
The government knew about the virus on January 3rd, had a CDC pandemic playbook to deal with it, yet outrageously Trump played down the danger, for over six weeks.
Soon after taking office, the Trump administration was warned by the Pentagon of an imminent epidemic danger; even so, the Trump administration closed down pandemic modelling by DHS in 2017. In 2018, the national security adviser John Bolton disbanded the White House pandemic office. 
In late 2018, Trump's administration received detailed plans, ordered by the Obama administration, for a new machine designed to produce millions of respirator masks quickly during a pandemic. The plans were discarded and the project abandoned. 
In 2019, the Trump administration failed to require the speedy delivery of low cost ventilators, developed by the Dutch multinational Philips under a contract funded by the Obama administration. Instead, the FDA approved the immediate sale of commercial versions, but gave Philips until September 2022 to supply the US. 
Philips stuck to its contract, absent the government's use of the Defence Procurement Act (see below), and its version of the government-funded ventilators is now being sold at an enormous mark-up around the world, with no priority granted to the US.
Other blunders: a 2019 pandemic exercise code-named "Crimson Contagion", simulated by the Trump administration's own Department of Health and Human Services, produced an alarming report on which no action was taken. Also, early intelligence reports on the government's frightening unpreparedness for a pandemic were ignored, despite Democrat pleas to act.
The president even toyed with letting the epidemic run its course, for the greater capitalist good, while some Republican senators with advance knowledge of the catastrophe sold off their endangered shares, buying into companies likely to profit from the crisis. More here and here.
Initially, Trump wrongly characterised his emergency powers under the DPA as "nationalisation", apparently to avoid civilian use of the Act; in fact, his administration has used the Act extensively for peacetime military procurement, including equipment for natural disasters.
Eventually, the president accepted crisis legislation that included a $500 billion discretionary fund that some feared was just another bailout for needy corporations, and, relaxing his ideological objections, allowed use of the DPA to procure ventilators from General Motors and others (including Philips) that he previously found too costly. 
While Trump dithered, US manufacturers exported critical equipment to buyers overseas. 
When crisis legislation was passed, it needed provisions to restrain Trump and other government insiders from profiting, and specified behaviour Trump was forbidden to engage in, e.g, diverting money to his Mexican wall. Still, there will be benefits for Trump, and in any case, he intends to ignore oversight provisions in the legislation (the House of Reps won't). 
In sum, President Trump, refusing any responsibility, has completely stuffed-up the virus response. 
Chances are, he'll get away with it. 
Just think. If the senate had done its job - removed the corrupt, incompetent Donald Trump from office - and afterwards, US marshals had succeeded in extracting him from his White House retreat, then the (comparatively) harmless Michael Pence would now be president, saving perhaps a few hundred thousand lives. 
With that in mind, an Intercept writer penned an open letter to Pence, encouraging him to move things along with the 25th amendment.

Wednesday, March 11, 2020

From Roger Fitch and our friends down under at Justinian

The rogue state

Trump running wild following the burlesque of his impeachment trial ... Retribution underway ... Regulatory bodies left inoperable ... Judges attacked ... Corruption rife - and no consequences ... Presidential pardons ... Political meddling in Roger Stone's trial ... SCOTUS to decide discrimination on the basis of religious beliefs ... A Supreme Court for the rich ... Roger Fitch on the case 
Following a sham senate trial in which some of his most lawless behaviour was excused by a slim majority of America's own "unrepresentative swill", an emboldened Donald Trump is running wild, while badgering away in his quest for re-election. 
He has heaps of money to spend, a friendly Fox News grooming his supporters 24/7, and a sympathetic supreme court prepared to take a "pro-partisanship turn", should he need it. Emily Bazelon has more.
Former cabinet members may characterise him as a moron, an idiot, and a man with the understanding of a 5th or 6th grader, but the president has cunning people behind him, with devious designs. 
One such practice is governing with unconfirmed acting officials (some appointed unlawfully). Another is  failing to fill vacant positions on important agency boards and regulatory commissions, thus leaving them "inquorate" and unable to perform their functions. The FEC, for instance, can't investigate Trump's many campaign finance violations. 
Since his senate acquittal, Mr Trump's megalomania and vindictiveness have become more pronounced, and his innate thuggery has led to post-impeachment purges of those who testified against him. There are, however, legal limits on Trump's reprisals against impeachment witnesses or other public servants, and it's a federal offence to retaliate against whistleblowers, more here.
Even so, with impeachment over, retribution has begun. Ferreting out unreliable or apostate political appointees is the special task of the former Heritage Foundation staffer, lobbyist and rightwing journalist Virginia Lamp Thomas. The wife of Justice Clarence Thomas, Ginni Thomas has often immersed herself in partisan Republican operations: in 2000, she actively assisted the George Bush election team while her husband considered Bush v Gore. 
•   •   •
Trump at another Taj Mahal 
Trump has dialed-up his shameful and unprecedented ad hominem attacks against courts and prosecutors: in his assault on justice he may have outdone Nixon. It's not just lower court judges like Amy Berman Jackson, who presided over the Roger Stone case, but individual supreme court justices, and even jurors. 
While in India (and visiting the real Taj Mahal, quite different from his eponymous twice-bankrupt casino), Mr Trump glimpsed a misleading "chyron" on Fox News, and instanter decided Justice Sotomayor would henceforth have to recuse herself from cases involving him - Justice Ginsburg, too. 
Alarmed, the federal judges' association called an emergency meeting to discuss how to deal with America's rogue president, a man who attacks the judiciary and whose attorney-general flouts court orders and disregards bedrock American law. 
•   •   •
There are many ways to fight corruption: Donald Trump's solution is to make it legal. Recently, he achieved a corruption milestone that will make him the envy of kleptocrats everywhere: 3000 conflicts of interest. That's besides the 19 policy changes that help (incidentally, of course) his businesses. 
Still awaiting examination are the Trump chaos trades. More here on Trump's apparent manipulations of markets for the benefit of insiders.
America now has corruption with no consequences, and it's a windfall for its most audaciously dishonest president. 
Occasionally, this corruption may take the form of presidential pardons. Or anticipatory reciprocity: birds of a feather look after one another. Thus it sometimes happens that a crooked Republican may be kind to a bent Democrat. 
"The Blag" - corrupt governor pardoned by Trump
It was no doubt in this spirit that Donald Trump responded with compassion to the pleas of the former Illinois governor Rod Blagojevich. The Blag was in prison for multiple federal offences, including trying to sell the vacant senate seat of Barack Obama, the object of Trump's obsessive fascination.
One could look upon it as a pardon in exchange for a "thing of value", though only in Trump's America would a convict's political endorsement be so regarded. 
At the same time, Mr Trump forgave other eminent white collar villains, who, aside from war criminals such as Eddie Gallagher and hagiographic biographers (e.g, Conrad Black), are the ones most likely to benefit from presidential mercy. With the instinctively venal Trump, other considerations may also play a part. Certainly, the latest batch all had "connections".
Some of those pardoned were not political and may have merited pardons, although publicly supporting Mr Trump seemed an advantage; it certainly helped if the president heard about you on Fox News. 
•   •   •
In the midst of all these pardons, the administration's interference in the Roger Stone trial stunned Washington. Donald Trump had tweeted that Stone's proposed sentence was too long, so it had to be reduced, and a DoJ sentencing memo was withdrawn and replaced with another, all within hours.
All four prosecuting US attorneys withdrew, and one left DoJ altogether, more here, while over 2000 former DOJ officials signed a petition that called for Barr's resignation.
Stone has now been sentenced, and Trump may well pardon him. Any pardon, however, may run up against the fact that Mr Trump has been impeached, and arguably, cannot afterwards pardon anyone whose behaviour was implicated in his impeachment
•   •   •
Obama's court appointments may have flipped the DC circuit to the Democrats, but a fortuitous Republican majority panel enabled former White House Counsel Don McGahn to unexpectedly win his DC circuit appeal against a congressional subpoena.
According to the shocking 2-1 decision, McGahn doesn't have to testify at all, executive privilege or otherwise, and the case was dismissed. This seemingly applies to all employees of the executive branch, an astonishing outcome. 
Barring en banc reconsideration, McGahn's case sets up a supreme court review where the Republican majority will undoubtedly pile on. It involved legal standing (that of congress), and the supreme court is not above manipulating standing to achieve desired outcomes. 
Linda Greenhouse has written about DoJ's machinations to prevent or remove standing for petitioners affected by and opposing  government actions. 
There are other subpoena cases before the supreme court; New York's brief in one of them is here.
There are distressing decisions rolling out of the supreme court, such as the cross-border shooting case. The court decided that it's all right for US border patrol agents to fatally shoot citizens of Mexico, so long as they die on the Mexican side. National security, and all that ... 
A major case yet to be decided is the "freedom of religion" case: i.e, whether a licence to discriminate must be accorded to those who ground their discrimination on religious beliefs. Dean Chemerinsky and Linda Greenhouse commented.
•   •   •
Supreme Inequality
A new book examines the historical tendency of the supreme court to serve the rich rather than the humble, and a recent case seemed to confirm this, when the court blessed Mr Trump's "wealth test" for immigrants by striking down lower court injunctions preventing its implementation pending appeals. 
Strangely, the fact one has applied for a green card may now be a basis for denying it. 
Think about that.